Interviews go both ways. Just as candidates are trying to put their best foot forward, hiring managers need to stay sharp and pay attention to the little details that might signal a deeper issue. It’s not always about what someone says, sometimes it’s how they say it, or even what they leave out, that reveals the most.
Noticing a red flag doesn’t mean you should immediately move on from a candidate. It just means you might need to slow down, ask a few more thoughtful questions, and dig a bit deeper. Here are five red flags to watch for during interviews, along with tips on how to handle them in a fair and professional way.
1. Vague or Too-Polished Answers
When a candidate responds with buzzwords, textbook phrases, or avoids getting into specifics, it could be a sign they’re lacking hands-on experience. People who’ve really done the work can usually walk you through the what, how, and why with clarity.
If you notice this, try switching things up and asking for a concrete example, like:
“Can you walk me through a specific project where you had to manage a tight deadline?”
This kind of prompt helps the candidate open up and show their actual approach, not just their theory.
2. Speaking Negatively About Past Employers or Teams
It’s normal to talk about past challenges, but when someone starts blaming former managers or throwing coworkers under the bus, it’s a red flag. Early negativity often signals unresolved issues or a tendency of deflecting responsibility.
Instead of cutting the conversation short, ask a follow-up like:
“What did you take away from that experience?” or “Looking back, would you approach it differently now?”
This gives them space to reflect, and shows you whether they’ve learned from the past or are still stuck in it.
3. Inconsistencies in Their Resume or Story
If job titles keep changing, dates don’t line up, or their story feels a little too flexible, don’t panic, but do dig in. It might be an honest mistake, or it could signal something deeper.
You might say:
“I noticed this role is listed as a manager position, but earlier you said you were supporting the team. Can you clarify your responsibilities there?”
This keeps the tone open and respectful, while making sure the picture is accurate.
4. No Questions at All
When you end an interview by asking “Any questions for me?” and receive a blank stare or a quick “no,” it’s a missed opportunity. Candidates who are truly interested usually want to know more.
If that happens, try asking:
“Is there anything you’re curious about, maybe the team, the way we work, or what success looks like in this role?”
This invites a more natural conversation and gives them another chance to show interest.
5. Culture Fit Feels Off
Sometimes everything checks out on paper, but something just feels off. Maybe their energy doesn’t click with your team, or their values don’t quite align. Trust your instincts.
Pay attention to how they talk about teamwork, feedback, and work-life balance. Are they aligned with your company’s vibe? If you’re unsure, it’s totally okay to bring in another team member for a second opinion.
Conclusion
Red flags don’t always mean a hard no, but they’re worth paying attention to. Interviews are your chance to learn more, ask better questions, and spot what might not be obvious at first glance.
At Linkrs, we believe hiring isn’t just about filling a position, it’s about building the right team, building trust, and setting everyone up for success.
So if something doesn’t feel quite right in your next interview, don’t brush it off. Lean in, ask the right questions, and see what the story really is.